Get The Advantage

With Offices in Ohio &  Indiana, and Serving All Customers Outside Those Areas

Are You Covered? Comprehensive Insurance Policies

Our insurance agency covers clients in 30 states with four offices. Advantage Insurance Agency is a regional force started from scratch in 1997 out of Ohio City, OH. Later, the office moved to Hamilton, OH, working with First Financial Bank toward the goal of providing products for clients in their geographical footprint. Eventually purchased by the producers from FFB.

About Advantage Insurance

In 2003 and 2004, we joined forces with our groups in Connersville, IN and Highland, IN. In 2009, we broke away from the bank and merged our Highland office with the Griffith, IN, office in 2014. Our newest office in Rushville, IN opened in spring of 2022.

In each of our offices, we offer comprehensive insurance policies for personal and business clients. Unlike the direct insurance companies, we have a long list of top-rated carriers of insurance companies

Our Customers

Business & Personal Policies

Restaurant Insurance


We provide business insurance to restaurant owners throughout Ohio and Indiana, Kentucky, Michigan, Illinois, Pennsylvania

Commercial Insurance

Commercial Real Estate

Commercial real estate companies rely on The Advantage when it comes to ensuring their business.

Equipment & Auto Dealership Insurance

Equipment & Auto Dealers

Advantage Insurance Agency offers insurance policies to equipment dealers and auto dealerships.

Home & Auto Insurance


Protect your landscaping business with an insurance policy you can count on.



If you work in manufacturing, get the insurance coverage you need.

Agriculture Insurance


Farms, both big and small, deserve quality insurance policies.

Workers Compensation Insurance

Workers Compensation

Our team has a workers compensation specialist on staff ready to help protect your business.

Auto Repair Insurance

Auto Repair

Auto repair shop owners trust our team to keep them protected against any unforeseen circumstances. 

Home & Auto Insurance

Home & Auto

Get home and auto insurance to protect your assets with Advantage today. Call us now for the best rates

Life Insurance

Life Insurance

Protect your family by finding the best life insurance policy for your personal situation.

Health Insurance

Health Insurance

We offer health insurance for businesses. Call now and get the advantage.

The Reliable Insurance Professionals

Our insurance company has grown each year by providing The Advantage for our clients. We have a unique process of working with our existing and prospective clients to gain knowledge about their situations. This assists us in building an organized insurance program with recommendations. We work to earn our clients’ trust and thereby create a relationship of open communication, allowing us to function more as our business clients’ in-house risk manager, thus providing The Advantage.

Commercial Endorsements

Years in Business

Agents & Staff To Serve You

Free Quote

Get a Free Quote Today from Advantage

Our Experienced Team has You Covered

Advantage Insurance Agency has a total of 21 employees, several of which have insurance company underwriting backgrounds. Partners in the group range in age from 28 to 64. These partners are focused on great service and the growth of our agency. With the number of companies we have to select from, we’ll have a fit for you with fantastic prices, terms, and conditions.

Contact Us and Get The Advantage Today

Contact one of our Indiana or Ohio insurance agency offices to schedule your business or personal insurance consultation with Advantage Insurance Agency.


Get In Touch

*Any description of coverage can only be determined by the insurance contract in place and can vary by insurance carrier.