About Us

About Willis Murphy Advantage Insurance Agency – Hamilton, OH

Willis Murphy Advantage Insurance Agency was founded in 1997 with the goal of providing The Advantage. We have three Agents: Mark Willis, Andy Murphy and Cristie Tillery. Our specialized niches include restaurants, banks, manufacturing, commercial real estate, and auto/truck repairs. From our office in Hamilton, OH, we serve from Southwest Ohio to Columbus and beyond. Willis Murphy Advantage Insurance Agency has clients in over 30 states.

Choose from our range of personal and business insurance policies today.

Willis Murphy Advantage Insurance Agency
Types of Insurance Offered

Providing the Advantage Since 1997

Our support staff consists of five full-time, licensed professionals dedicated to delivering excellent service, keeping our clients happy, and providing them The Advantage. We also have The Advantage of three other offices that can help us if we’re ever in need.

How The Advantage Works

We learn the individual situations and develop an understanding of businesses to aid in working on recommendations for terms and conditions. This helps us know our client’s story and advocate for them to our insurance companies. The presentations we make to insurance companies about our prospects and clients keep our submissions at the top of the underwriting stack. This is a benefit for our clients from a pricing and coverage standpoint. 


What We Offer

We provide business insurance, personal insurance, life, disability, and group health products.

Business insurance is our specialty – from Banks to manufacturers, real-estate to restaurants, equipment dealers to auto repair, and landscapers to farms (both big and small).

Property & Complex Casualty Placements

Property & Complex Casualty Placements

  • Property & Complex Casualty Placements
  • Workers Compensation Programs
  • Owner/Contractor Controlled Programs
  • REO and Force-Placed Insurance and Tracking Services
  • Loss Control Services
  • Risk Management Consulting
  • National Franchise Accounts
  • International Coverages
  • Invoicing and allocation of premium
  • On-line, Self-Service Certificate Systems
Professional Liability Insurance

Executive Liability

  • Private & Public Company Directors & Officer Liability
  • Employment Practices
  • Fiduciary Liability
Professional Liability

Professional Liability

  • Bankers, Physicians, Attorneys, Lawyers, Engineers
  • Environmental Liability
  • Site Pollution
  • Contractor Pollution
  • Secured Lender

Meet the Team

Mark Willis

Mark Willis

President at Willis Murphy Advantage Insurance Agency

An insurance professional now for 35+ years with the goal of growing the business one relationship at a time. Using our unique process we call The Advantage to learn about each organizations’ and individuals’ situation is how we are able to create a recommendation for next steps. This is our proprietary process and what I believe sets us a part from other agents. Get The Advantage!



Andy Murphy

Andy Murphy

Risk Management and Commercial Insurance

I am a Risk Manager, Commercial Insurance Specialist and Partner in a regional independent insurance agency. My objective is to help businesses, business owners and their employees minimize risk and to adequately insure themselves against loss on a cost-effective basis with stable insurance companies.

Cristie Tillery

Cristie Tillery

Risk Advisor and Vice President of Business Development

Cristie is a highly motivated insurance risk advisor for Business, Personal, Life, & Group Health insurance. She became a licensed professional in 2018, following her graduation from Miami University where she earned a Bachelors degree in Mathematics and Statistics. Cristie provides The Advantage to her clients from her experience as an insurance account manager. She has formed a strong relationship with our insurance companies and understands how to advocate for her clients and their unique needs.

Insurance Careers with Cristie Tillery

Contact Us and Get The Advantage Today

Contact one of our Indiana or Ohio insurance agency offices to schedule your business or personal insurance consultation with Advantage Insurance Agency.


Get In Touch

*Any description of coverage can only be determined by the insurance contract in place and can vary by insurance carrier.